The Best Pizza
From The Old Neighborhood

Yeah, you remember…



Once  upon a time, every neighborhood had their own pizza shop where the locals knew the guys working there and the same faces were seen for years and years.  A place you could go with your family or friends, a place to make new friends, a place to feel comfortable and sit back and relax. You’ve found that place. The Doughfather pizzeria has quickly become a Monroe staple.

We are dedicated to offering authentic Italian cuisine of both classic and modern traditions, and delicious pizza in a warm and inviting atmosphere.  No matter what the day brings, we mak sure each meal we serve is delicious and one-of-a-kind. Let us invite you into our house where everyone is treated like family and the chef/owner takes the time to get to know his customers.  So come by for a slice, stay for dinner, take in the friendly atmosphere, relax and enjoy.  We look forward to welcoming you soon!
  • Home
  • Home
  • Home
  • Home
    • 5 star review  Ordered a Sicilian tonight , I’m guessing the order got crossed w the lack of a POS system, but when the owner realized it he gave me the pizza and my money back and said “ this ones got a flat tire, this ain’t what I normally make “ got it home and it was thinner than a Sicilian, but the man stood behind his product!! being that this place is LITERALLY right across the street from me, he will be seeing my face quite often.

      thumb Rodger Meaney
    • 5 star review  Just tried the Stillwell pizza and it was AMAZING! Hands down the BEST pizza I've ever had since moving to New Jersey from Brooklyn 26 years ago. Definitely ordering again!! I have found my favorite pizza place, finally! The staff is super nice also and answered all of my questions. Highly recommend this place!

      thumb Jennifer Wands
    • 5 star review  Absolutely had the best Sicilian pizza o I ever had went early Monday to pick up menu my wife called in the order later in the day service was exceptional Pizza was fluffy and cheese quality was very good not oily proper amount of sauce on there I could’ve used a little more it was perfectly fine was baked brown temperature was right on point and most importantly the taste was exceptional in the next day and even reheat it properly I am going to try the other dishes I can see myself being at least twice a week as long as I’m in New Jersey

      thumb Dave Infosino
    • 5 star review  Picked up some real NY style pizza on the way home from work. 2 Sicilians and 3 regular slices. Pizza was delicious and knocks all the pizza in the area out of the box. I give them a rating of out of 5. I’ll definitely be back.

      thumb Pete Vaz
    • 5 star review  We ordered the garlic knot pizza and it lived up to all the reviews. My husband is from Brooklyn and it is very hard to please him with pizza but this is authentic Brooklyn pizza. We cannot wait to try the other pies.

      thumb Danielle Wunderlich
    • 5 star review  I ordered the stillwell pizza ahead of time and it was delicious!!! I can swim in a pool of their delicious sauce!! And the cookie pie was awesome!!! We are very excited about this place!! Welcome to the neighborhood!!!

      thumb Gabriela De Vacca
    • 5 star review  Walked in today to try it out and was pleasantly surprised. The place looks great, pizza was fresh and everyone who works there could not have been nicer. The gelato, I got pistachio, was soo good! Totally recommended!

      thumb Tanya Ferenc Spector
    • 5 star review  Finally got around to trying a pizza from them. The pizza was great. The pie had a good amount of cheese, sauce had excellent flavor plus it was cooked just right and had a nice crispy crust. I'll definitely be back.

      thumb Jim Smith
    • 5 star review  What’s not to love??? Aside from pizzas, I think the shrimp Oreganata is out of this world. Highly recommend that dish if you like shrimp.

      thumb Dina Shafran
  • Quality Ingredients

    The Dougfather uses only the best,
    and you deserve the best.

    Fast Delivery

    Need it now? Fuggedaboutit!
    We got you covered.

    Classic Favorites

    From the old neighborhood.
    Just like you remember.​

    Quality Ingredients

    The Dougfather uses only the best,
    and you deserve the best.

    Fast Delivery

    Need it now? Fuggedaboutit!
    We got you covered.

    Classic Favorites

    From the old neighborhood.
    Just like you remember.​

    It's Your Birthday!

    Spin & Win
    up to $75 in Doughfather money!

    Come in the within a week of your birthday and take a spin on the Wheel

    * Valid Id required
    * Spin On Wheel with a purchase
    The Birthday Wheel
    is BACK!

    Planning an upcoming event?

    Whether it is a backyard barbecue, an intimate affair, or the biggest day of your life, let The Doughfather design the perfect menu for the perfect experience.

    7 Taylor Ave
    Monroe Township, NJ 08831
    Monday - Thursday10:30 AM — 9:00 PM
    Friday - Saturday10:30 AM — 11:30 PM
    Sunday10:30 AM — 9:00 PM
    • 732-251-2523

    Join the Festival

    Our Sausage & Pepper Stand is OPEN!

    Play Video